#11 Folsom Prison Tramp-Stamp Blues

Welcome back to the super profesh and clean sound quality. This week Mariel sticks to storytelling with that of Antonina Makarova, a nazi-collaborator throughout WWII. She would become known as “Machine-Gun Girl” for her role as an executioner. Then Amanda tells a tale of meth, prison, and love at first sight. That is the story of Cynthia Coffman and James Marlow. If we learn anything from this story, let it be that if ever you’re going to get married on a top of a motorcycle, take lots of pictures.

Thank you for listening! 

If you enjoy our show, subscribe, leave a 5-star review and tell a friend! That’s the best way to support the show.  Our goal is to have 50 reviews on Apple Podcasts!

Listen Here: Folsom Prison Tramp-Stamp Blues

Antonina Makarova mugshot, 1920
Photo Found Here
Antonina Makarova while in the military
Photo Found Here
Young Antonina Makarova
Photo Found Here
Antonina Makarova being Identified 
Photo Found Here
Cynthia Coffman mugshot
Photo Found Here
Corinna Dell Novis, victim, age 20
Photo Found Here
Lynell Murray, victim, age 19
Photo Found Here
James Marlow post arrest
Photo Found Here
Cynthia Coffman’s hand with Wold tattoo
Photo Found Here
Surrvaillence of Cynthia Coffman and James Marlow
Photo Found Here
Recent mugshot of Cynthia Coffman
Photo Found Here

#10 John Wilkes Booth Trap House

This week, Amanda gives us a history lesson that we didn’t learn in school. The story of Mary Surratt and the conspiracy to assassinate President Abe Lincoln. Mariel deep dives into a tragic crime and trial that led to the conviction of young Texas mom, Darlie Routier, and the latest update to her case as of 2019. Then some humble opinions about a very creepy “Yogi master.” If this episode sounds a little different then our previous shows, it’s because Mariel produced it!* Usually, we have our professional producer mix & master our episodes, but she was up for the challenge. 

Thank you to all our listeners! If you’d like to help us out, please download our episodes and leave a 5-star review wherever you are listening. Our goal is to hit 50 reviews on Apple Podcasts!

Listen Here: John Wilkes Booth Trap House

Darlie, Devon(left), Drake(center), and Damon(right) Routier 
Photo Found Here
Darlie’s Injuries
Photo Found Here
Devon (right) and Damon (left)
Photo Found Here
Screenshot of The Last Defense which aired on 20/20,  the infamous silly string video
The Last Defense 20/20 video
Mary Surratt
Photo Found Here
Surratt Boarding House
Photo Found Here
John Wilkes Booth
Photo Found Here
The four convicted conspirators (from top left: David Harold, Lewis Powell, Mary Surratt, George Atzerodt)
Photo Found Here
The death warrant being read before the execution of the 4 conspirators
Photo Found Here

#9 Yello Mama

This week Amanda explains the case against Emilia Carr and her role in the tragic murder of Heather Strong. Then Mariel tells the story of Lynda Lyon Block and the dangers of homegrown extremism. Amanda and Mariel also talk plot holes, Netflix’s “You” plus a horrific and recent murder side-story. Happy New Year! Thank you for your continued support!

For content related to this episode visit our Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.

Listen Here: Yello Mama

Emilia Carr before arrest and after, age 30
Photo Found Here
Heather Strong, victim
Photo Found Here
Joshua Folgham mugshot
Photo Found Here
Emilia Carr
Photo Found Here
The location where Heather Strong was killed, owed by the family of Emilia Carr
Photo Found Here
Linda Lyon Block 
Photo Found Here
Sgt Roger Motley
Photo Found Here
Lynda Lyon and George Sibley after surrendering to police
Photo Found Here
George Sibley Jr
Photo Found Here
Yellow Mama
Photo Found Here

#8 Merry Christmas, Happy Halliday!

Happy Holidays, listeners and remember that you are innocent until proven naughty!

Couldn’t resist that pun for this week’s episode title because Amanda tells us the old-timey story of Lizzie Halliday, New York’s first known female serial killer and Mariel tells a tale of sad misfortune, hear the crimes of Tanya Nelson, the fortune teller murderer.

Thank you for listening! If you enjoy the show and would like to show your support, leave us a review, subscribe and download our new episodes every week!

Listen Here: Merry Christmas, Happy Halliday!

Anita Vo Smith
Photo Found Here
Tanya Nelson
Photo Found Here
Phillipe Zamora, accomplice 
Photo Found Here
Police poster of Lizzie Halliday
Photo Found Here
Arrest Poster for Lizzie Halliday
Photo Found Here
The McQuillan Sisters
Photo Found Here
Where the bodies of the McQuillan sisters were found, 1893
Photo Found Here

#7 That Criminal Mind

This episode Amanda and Mariel briefly discuss the Ryan Ferguson case and the corrupt prosecutor, Kevin Crane. Mariel shares some thoughts on Ted Bundy. Then Amanda discusses the cruel death of 10-year-old Emani Moss, followed by the story of husband killer Wendi Andriano by Mariel.

Listen Here: That Criminal Mind

Tiffany Moss
Photo Found Here
Emani Moss, age 10
Photo Found Here
Tiffany Moss
Photo Found Here
Wendi Adriano
Photo Found Here
Wendi and Joe Andriano
Photo Found Here

#6 THIS IS LIKE DEJA VU ALL OVER AGAIN!

This week, hot takes on Netflix’s “The Confession Killer,” Henry Lee Lucas, and the Texas Rangers. Mariel’s head explodes, and as a duet, she and Amanda tell the story of a young mother wrongfully convicted of a horrible crime against her young son. Debra Milke would spend 22 years on Arizona’s death row. To learn more about protecting those who are innocent and wrongful conviction prevention, visit The Innocence Network

Listen Here: THIS IS LIKE DEJA VU ALL OVER AGAIN!

Debra Jean Milke
Photo Found Here
Debra Jean Milke
Photo Found Here
Christopher and Debra Milke
Photo Found Here


Christopher Milke
Photo Found Here


James Styers
Photo Found Here


Roger Scott
Photo Found Here
Former Arizona Detective Armando Saldate
Photo Found Here

#5 Oops… we did it again

Drugs are bad! In this episode, Amanda and Mariel tag-team the story of The Texas Pick-Axe Murderess. That’s what happens when you decide to surprise one another every week with a different story. Maybe it’s a sister thing, almost like a sixth-sense…


Listen Here: Oops… we did it again

Karla Faye Tucker mugshot, 1984
Photo Found Here
Jerry Lynn Dean and Deborah Thorton
Photo Found Here
Daniel Garrett, accomplice
Photo Found Here
Karla Faye Tucker
Photo Found Here
Image result for karla faye tucker
Karla Faye Tucker
Photo Found Here

#4 Lisa and Sue are F***ing Awful

Amanda tells us about a tragic fetal abduction, which resulted in the death of the mother-to-be, Bobbie Jo Stinnett. Then Mariel tells us the horrible tale of the cruel killing in 1998 of 59-year-old Louis “Buddy” Musso by a woman who would become the 14th woman executed in the modern era US.

Listen Here: Lisa and Sue are F***cking Awful

Lisa Marie Montgomery
Photo Found Here
Bobbi Jo Stinnett
Photo Found Here
Lisa Marie Montgomery with one of her Rat Terriers
Photo Found Here
Pregnant Bobbi Jo Stinnett with one of her Rat Terriers
Photo Found Here
Suzanne Basso 1999 Mugshot
Photo Found Here
Louis “Buddy” Musso, victim
Photo Found Here
Suzanne Basso + Accomplices
Photo Found Here

#3 “Death Row Granny” and Texas “Killer Babe”

In this episode, Mariel tells us about a brutal murder and robbery, which led to the conviction of a Texas woman; an internet list called her “one of the ten most attractive Death Row inmates in the United States.” Then Amanda tells the story of “The Death Row Granny.” Also featuring hot-takes on Scientology and Bingeing the new Netflix series, The Politician.

Listen Here: “Death Row Granny” and Texas “Killer Babe”

Brittany Marlowe Holberg – “Killer Babe”
Photo Found Here
Brittany Marlowe Holberg’s mugshot
Photo Found Here
A.B. Towery, victim of Brittany Holberg
Photo Found Here
Son of A.B. Towery
Photo Found Here
Velma Margie Barfield
Photo Found Here
Margie Velma Barfield
Photo Found Here
Velma’s last meal
Photo Found Here

#2 Germany’s Secret Hero & The Sabrina Butler Story

In this episode, we begin with a death penalty related story, then Amanda tells us about the woman from Wisconsin who was sentenced to death by Hitler and Mariel talks about that time Mississippi sentenced a teenage mother to death.

Listen Here:“Germany’s Secret Hero” and the Sabrina Butler Story

Mildred Fish-Harnack

Mildred Fish-Harnack

Mildred Fish-Harnack
Photo Found Here
Detailed record of Mildred Harnack 
Photo Found Here
Mildred and Arvid Harnack
Photo Found Here
Mildred Harnack’s mugshot
Photo Found Here
Walter, the baby whose death Sabrina was convicted for.
Walter D. Butler
Photo Found Here

Sabrina Butler
Photo Found Here

Sabrina Butler
Photo Found Here